What Is Actually Optional? A Guide to Making the Right Decision.

Key Takeaways

  • Optional components should help admissions officers understand something new about you
  • Different optional sections solve different problems, from providing context to showcasing evidence of your work.
  • Strong optional materials grow out of genuine experiences and long-term interests, not last-minute efforts to check another box.


As you work through your college applications, you’ll probably notice the word “optional” appearing more often than you expected.

Optional essays. Optional test scores. Optional video introductions. Optional portfolios. Optional sections.

Then you might wonder:

If it’s optional, why is it there?

Some students assume every optional component is secretly required and feel pressure to complete every available section. Others skip every optional opportunity without considering whether it could strengthen their application.

Neither approach is ideal.

The strongest applications aren’t built by completing every optional section. Instead, they’re built by making thoughtful decisions about what actually helps admissions officers understand you.

Does Optional Ever Mean Required?

At its core, optional means optional. Colleges do not automatically reject applicants because they chose not to submit optional materials.

Instead, optional components exist because not every applicant needs the same opportunities to provide context or evidence. Some students have circumstances that deserve explanation. Others have years of artistic work, research, or projects that can’t be fully represented elsewhere in the application. And many students don’t need to use these optional sections at all.

Rather than asking, “Should I complete every optional section?”, ask yourself:

Will this help admissions officers understand me better?

Every optional component on a college application exists for a different reason. Before you decide to take on an optional section or not, it’s important to understand what each section is trying to help you convey.

Optional for Context

Your college application gives you some options to expand upon your context. Here are some examples:

Additional Information Section

The Additional Information section is used to provide a brief explanation of your circumstances or experiences that have impacted things you have included on the rest of your application or to clarify things that an admissions officer could misunderstand.

Students should not be treating this as an extension of their personal statement; it should be written in a concise, factual way.

It can help explain things like:

  • illness
  • family obligations
  • school disruptions
  • curriculum limitations at your high school
  • grading policies

This section allows students to clarify circumstances and provide important context for their application.

This section could also be used to elaborate on specific activities or achievements that require a larger explanation than the Activities or Honors lists provide.

Things like:

  • Major awards
  • Unique clubs, organizations, or projects
  • Unusual classes

This section is the perfect opportunity to add where other sections couldn’t.

But many times, students do not have much to add to this section. That’s why it is optional. 

There’s no need to exaggerate excuses, to inflate your achievements, or to repeat information that you’ve already covered.

Sometimes, the wiser decision might be to leave it blank.

Video Introduction

An increasing number of colleges are asking applicants to submit brief video introductions as part of their application.

Video introductions have different requirements for each college. Some may ask for 60-second clips, and others may ask for up to two-minute videos. Some colleges allow applicants to record and edit their videos in advance, while others ask students to record their responses in a single take.

Video introductions are often optional, but they can be worth submitting to offer another way to demonstrate your personality beyond what admissions officers read on paper. As Brown University’s Dean of Admission Logan Powell explains, video introductions provide a more complete picture of who you are beyond your essays and activities.

Many colleges intentionally keep the prompt broad.

Students might:

  • introduce a hobby they genuinely enjoy
  • explain a tradition that’s meaningful to them
  • share a curiosity they’ve pursued
  • describe a community that’s shaped them

Video introductions aren’t meant to be polished productions. Admissions officers are generally less interested in cinematic effect and are more interested in seeing your genuine personality.

Optional for Evidence

Other optional sections can be used to provide more evidence of your work.

The biggest example of these is called optional supplements. Some colleges allow students to submit materials that may be difficult to fully convey through activities, essays, or transcripts alone.

This includes:

  • Art portfolios
  • Maker/Enginering portfolios
  • Research uploads
  • Performance videos

These additions to your college application are most effective when they provide real evidence of depth in a specific area.

If you’ve spent years playing the violin, you can include a performance.

If you’ve gotten research published, you can include some of that.

If you’ve spent all of high school developing your art portfolio, you can submit that.

But with all that said, you shouldn’t be submitting extra material just to appear more accomplished. The strongest optional materials usually aren’t created because a college application asked for them. They are the natural result of years spent exploring an interest, developing a skill, or pursuing meaningful work.

If you have that kind of evidence, you can submit it. But if you don’t, that’s fine too.

When Optional Can Matter

Then, there are some optional materials that stump students. Let’s go through them:

Test-Optional

Students are usually most hesitant with this. Although many schools have test-optional policies, students still stress over the decision of whether to submit or not.

A common guideline is to compare your score with the middle 50% of admitted students. If your score falls comfortably within or above that range and strengthens your academic profile, submitting it may be beneficial. If not, withholding your score remains an option.

However, students shouldn’t treat test-optional as a safeguard. In recent admissions cycles, top schools have switched back from test-optional to test-required policy. Be aware of this before you get to senior year.

If standardized testing isn’t one of your strengths, focus on building the rest of your academic profile through rigorous coursework and strong grades rather than assuming test-optional policies will remain in place.

Optional Supplemental Essays

Some colleges list some of their supplemental essays as optional. 

If you have a thoughtful response that adds meaningful insight to your application, it’s usually worth completing. 

Completing an optional supplemental essay can signal that you’ve invested additional thought into how you fit that particular institution. More importantly, it gives you another opportunity to help admissions officers understand why you’re a strong match for that school.

However, if you are going to write more, make sure each essay gives unique insight that paints you as a stronger fit for the university.

The Best Optional Materials Aren’t Forced

After knowing about all of these extra aspects of a college application, students shouldn’t scramble to put something together just to check extra boxes.

Optional materials are most useful when they are naturally created from the student’s actual experiences, strengths, and circumstances rather than from anxiety about appearing to be perfect.

If you’re a student who has already invested time into independent research or projects, it’s not a bad idea to compile them to include on your college application.

If you have been worried about extenuating circumstances, you have the opportunity to explain your situation to colleges.

But optional materials should not be made up because they all have one thing in common: they show authenticity.

They show the hours you have put in, the passions you have invested in, and the circumstances that you have endured. They show colleges the fuller picture.

But if you don’t have more to show, leaving these sections blank is a fine option too.


Final Thoughts

Optional components exist because they solve different problems. That means that not everyone needs to submit the same things to get their point across. 

The strongest applications aren’t the ones with the most optional materials. They’re the ones where every submission has a clear purpose.

So once you get to these sections on your college application, don’t just ask whether something is optional.

Ask what purpose it serves.

Leave a Reply